Former Bel-Aire PTO president indicted for theft

A Coffee County grand jury has indicted a former Volunteer of the Year and former Bel-Aire Elementary School PTO President, Samantha Zimmerman, after state investigators said she misappropriated at least $57,522.62 from the Tullahoma school’s parent-teacher organization.

Zimmerman faces one count of theft over $10,000, two counts of forgery and two counts of tampering with governmental records, according to the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office. Investigators identified $20,000 in repayments, leaving $37,522.62 unrecovered.

The investigation began after Tullahoma City Schools officials reported financial discrepancies. Zimmerman served as PTO president from August 2023 until she resigned Jan. 29, 2026.

Investigators attributed $31,820.49 to cash withdrawals from the PTO’s bank account and $21,215.86 to personal purchases on its debit card. Zimmerman told investigators she made withdrawals for personal use. Debit card purchases included clothing, food, entertainment, and vehicle maintenance and storage rentals. Investigators found five of the six storage units paid for with PTO funds were for Zimmerman’s personal use.

Investigators said Zimmerman also misappropriated at least $4,486.27 in fundraiser and Venmo collections and submitted false annual financial reports to school officials. In August 2025, she reported a PTO bank balance of $34,938. Bank records showed less than $1,900 around the time she submitted the report.

The Comptroller’s Office separately identified at least $77,307.96 in questionable PTO payments that investigators could not verify because the organization lacked adequate receipts, invoices and other records.

Comptroller Jason Mumpower said school support organizations should divide financial duties among officers so one person does not control deposits, spending and bank reconciliations without oversight.

Staff Report
Staff Report
Articles: 405